Homes for sale in Settlers' Mill in Williamsburg

Homes for sale in Settlers' Mill in Williamsburg

Homes for sale in Settlers' Mill

An elegant, established community of 156 acres of rolling hills and mature wooded areas, Settlers' Mill includes 200 homes. These fine properties exude comfortable, Southern sophistication  Just three miles from shopping and dining, and only 2 1/2 miles from Historic Jamestown,  James River Beach Park and the Jamestown-Scotland ferry, Settler's Mill is the ideal hybrid of country and town living.  

History: Settlers' Mill development began in 1989. Local builders Wayne Harbin and Gordon Berryman completed many of the homes in the neighborhood.  

Lots and Prices: There are 200 properties with lots ranging in size from 0.34 acres to nearly 1 acre. The average list  price for homes in Settlers' Mill is between $350,000 and $600,000. Most homes have between 3,000 and 5,000 square feet of living space.


Clubhouse hosting social events for adults and children


Picnic pavilion

Tennis courts

Homeowner's Association: Membership in Settlers' Mill Homeowner's Association is mandatory. Fees are $50 per month and include use of the amenities.

Schools: Residents of Settlers' Mill attend Williamsburg-James City County schools, including Byrd Elementary, Berkeley Middle and Jamestown High. Local institutions of higher education include Thomas Nelson Community College and The College of William and Mary.

Commuting: Settlers' Mill is ideally located for commuters. Driving time to Fort Eustis is about 30 minutes, Langley Air Force Base 45 minutes and Richmond one hour.

Similar Communities: Holly Hills, Landfall at Jamestown, Port Anne

View map

To find the perfect home in Settlers' Mill, contact Deelyn at 757.503.1999 or [email protected]



     Deelyn Neilson on Zillow